The Spirituality of the Christian East — 20160305

The very last step on John’s LADDER is FAITH, HOPE AND LOVE. John writes, And now at last, after all that has been said, there remains that triad, faith, hope and love, binding and securing the union of all. “But the greatest of these is love”, since that is the very name of God Himself. To me they appear, one as a ray, one as light and one as a disk,” and all as a single radiance and a single splendor.

We have reached the pinnacle of the LADDER, the summit of virtue, which is love. But from the above passage it is clear that just as Christians speak of God as Trinity and never as Father, Son and Holy Spirit in isolation from one another, so too when we speak of love, we cannot do so without including faith and hope. These three virtues – faith, hope, and love – are the “Holy Trinity” of the spiritual life. Without the former virtues, love becomes only a vague sentiment. When we see all three as one virtue, we are able to have a better grasp of what love means.

Paul says in his first letter to Timothy, God “desires all men and women to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth”. John says in his Gospel that Jesus is the way, the truth and the life”. So love, as a Christian virtue, or rather the Christian virtue which embraces all virtues, is rooted in the knowledge of God. This is why Eastern Christian mysticism is never separated from dogma and theology. The purpose of both doctrine and mysticism is to know the true God, who is love.

Love, by its nature, is a resemblance to God, insofar as this is humanly possible. In its activity it is inebriation of the soul. Its distinctive character is to be a fountain of faith, an abyss of patience, a sea of humility.

Only the dispassionate can acquire perfect faith, hope and love, but we cannot even make a true beginning of spiritual life if we do not possess these virtues to some degree.

More to follow!

CALLED TO HOLINESS — 20160305

I don’t know if any of my readers have ever thought about this, but the purpose of this life on earth is to imitate Jesus Who worked to make God’s Kingdom real during His lifetime. If we truly become engaged in making our God’s Kingdom real during our lifetime, we will be changed – transformed into God’s children. For to work for the establishment of the Kingdom, we have to become people who see the importance of “love of neighbor”. Love of neighbor, however, requires that we are ready and willing to not only forgive our neighbors but also accept them as they are. This process changes us.

When we refuse to be bigoted, prejudiced, judgmental, hateful and unloving, we change and God’s Kingdom become a little more real in our world. We are the instruments that He has chosen to bring about His Kingdom in the here and now.

I find that when people only think about God’s Kingdom as something that will only transpire in the future after death, they are not as concerned about making it real at the present time. Jesus was concerned about transforming His society NOT IN THE FUTURE but DURING HIS LIFETIME. That is why He was willing to die in order to give true life to His teaching. It is only in the present moment that we can change. Now is the time to give ourselves to spiritually growth and development. This present life, as God designed it, allows us multiple opportunities to spiritually grow if only we seize the moment. AND, just keeping rules will not bring about spiritual development. Personal transformation is the result of actively trying to make ourselves grow in the image and likeness of Jesus. That is the primary task of life. That is the true meaning of life! Ask yourself this:

What does it mean to me to be a Christian?

Learning Our Faith From the Greek Fathers of the Church — 20160305

As I shared in the last issue of this article, the Arian heresy began when Arius refused to accept Alexander’s formulations about Jesus. If the Son, Arius exclaimed, possesses the same divine nature as the Father – is “consubstantial” with him – then “the Father is compound and divisible and alterable and a body, and according to them presumably, the bodiless God is though of as suffering what belongs to a body.”

The Father, Arius insisted, cannot share his divine nature with another. He is by definition simple (not made up of parts) and indivisible (incapable of division into parts). Hence, whoever and whatever the Son is, he cannot be The eternally God, uncreated and consubstantial with the Father. Some other definition regarding the Son will have to be formulated, and Arius appoints himself for the task.

“What is it that we say, and think, and have taught, and teach?” Arius asks Eusebius.

That the Son is not unbegotten, nor a part of the unbegotten in any way, nor formed out of any substratum, but that he was constituted by “God’s will and counsel, before times and before ages, full of grace and truth, divine, unique, unchangeable. And before he was begotten or created or ordained or founded, he was not. For he was not unbegotten. We are persecuted because we say, “The Son has a beginning, but God is without beginning.” For this we are persecuted, and because we say, “he is made out of things that were not.” But this is what we say, since he is neither a part of God nor formed out of any substratum. For this we are persecuted, and you know the rest.

Frankly, Arius seems to want his cake and to eat it, too. On the one hand, he wants to affirm that the Son is in some way divine. On the other hand, if Arius is to preserve God’s simplicity and indivisibility, he must affirm that the Son has a beginning, even if he posits this as a beginning outside of time as we know it. Arius asserts, then, that the Son was “begotten timelessly by the Father and created before ages and established.” Arius admits that the Son is utterly unique – “He alone was constituted by the Father – yet the Son is “neither eternal nor coeternal nor co-unbegotten with the Father, nor does he have his being together with the Father.”

The Divine Liturgy and Our Worship of God — 20160305

As we enter into the Great Fast and worship our God using the Liturgy of St. Basil the Great, we are also drawn into a detailed description of what we believe about our God. We pray this:

Who indeed is able to describe adequately Your deeds of might or proclaim the wondrous works you have performed at all times?

Our Church indeed calls us to stand in awe before our God. St. Basil shares with us the characteristics of our God when we pray:

You Who are without beginning, invisible, incomprehensible, unbounded and unchangeable

In light of these words, I would ask you to recall the challenge I gave you on the Weekend of the Prodigal Son, namely to assess your understanding of Who God is and to change that understanding to what God is as He as He has revealed Himself to be through the Church. When we really understand that we, as His creations, cannot change even one iota of His disposition toward us by our actions, we will begin to spiritually grow.

I truly believe that if we only see God as a Judge and an all-powerful being that demands we act a certain way or be punished, we can never respond to His love and can never truly become His children. We see that Jesus, despite the grave challenges He had to face, always thought of His Father as “Abba”, truly an affectionate term that expressed the fact the Jesus understood that the Father loved Him and that He, in turn, desired to voluntarily return the Father’s love. St. Basil, in the first prayer of the Anaphora, continues the prayer by addressing who the Son and Holy Spirit are. The prayer states that the Lord Jesus Christ is:

Great God and Redeemer, our hope, Who is the image of Your goodness, the seal of Your own likeness, showing You forth in Himself, O Father – the living Word, true God, eternal Wisdom, life, Sanctification, Power, the true light.

St. Basil then states that Jesus is the One through Whom

The Holy Spirit manifested Himself; the Spirit of truth, the gift of the adoption of Son, the pledge of our future inheritance, the first fruits of everlasting blessedness, the life-giving power, the found of sanctification, through Whom every creature possessed of reason and understanding is given the power to serve You (Father) and to send up to You an unending hymn of glory, because all things are Your subjects.

PASTORAL LETTER OF HIS BEATITUDE SVIATOSLAV TO THE FAITHFUL OF THE UKRAINIAN GREEK CATHOLIC CHURCH AND TO ALL PEOPLE OF GOOD WILL ON THE OCCASION OF THE 125th ANNIVERSARY OF THE BIRTH OF PATRIARCH JOSYF SLIPYJ


Lord, teach me to do Your will, for You are my God. (Ps. 143:10) Dear Sisters and Brothers in Christ! February 17th of this year marks the 125th anniversary of the birth of Patriarch Josyf Slipyj – Confessor of the faith and longtime Primate of our Church. The Synod of Bishops of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church has instructed all the faithful to honor his memory this entire year and to pray for his glorification here on earth among the choir of the blessed and the saints. The life of Patriarch Josyf has passed by in the whirlwind of the complex and dramatic events of the 20th century. He, like no other, endured almost all of the burdens and the sufferings of that historical period. His life lay against the backdrop of revolutions and two World Wars, the breakup of empires and the ever-changing state borders; he underwent imprisonment, exile and, finally, forced emigration… The Patriarch joined to himself the experiences of a hundred thousand or even of millions of Ukrainians, for whom these decades became the true via dolorosa per aspera ad astra (Way of the Cross through hardships to the stars). To be precise, this motto – “Through hardships to the stars” – Josyf Slipyj put on his episcopal coat of arms in 1939. His clandestine episcopal consecration took place under conditions when the Church was being persecuted during the Soviet occupation of Western Ukraine. Metropolitan Andrei Sheptytsky, confined by a serious illness to a wheelchair, tried to provide successive leadership for the Church and searched for an individual, “whom no trials could break”. The young bishop Josyf probably felt that his ministry would become a path through hardships. However, as the stars act as a guide for the sailor not to become lost on the stormy seas, so the light of Christ, that enlightens all, did become the guide for the future patriarch in his own life and in ministering to others. He came into this world, a subject of the AustroHungarian monarchy, and left it as an outcast of the last empire of the 20th century – the Soviet Empire. In his childhood, young Josyf dreamed of becoming a priest or a scholar. With the blessing and support of Vladyka Andrei Sheptytsky he was able to realize and join together these two great callings, even though external circumstances did not always contribute to their full realization. His years as a student coincided with the unrest of World War I and the desperate attempts of our people to gain independence and to unite into one state. Josyf Slipyj received his priestly ordination from the hands of Metropolitan Andrei in September of 1917 upon the Metropolitan’s return from Russian captivity. His higher theological studies were in Innsbruck, and then in Rome, amid the postwar devastation and the great socio-political and spiritual-moral crises in Europe of that time. In 1922, after completing his learning abroad, Father Josyf returned to a new political reality in his homeland. This time it was a restored Polish [Second] Republic, in which Ukrainians again found themselves in the role of a discriminated national and religious minority. This is why the Head of our Church entrusted to him the leadership of the Theological Seminary, the establishment of the Ukrainian Theological Scientific Society, and the development of the Greek Catholic Theological Academy in L’viv, which became the leading scientific and educational centers not only for Church circles, but even generally for the Ukrainian community of Halychyna (Galicia). And ahead lay an even greater test – the Second World War. The Ukrainian “bloodlands” collided with the center of contact of two totalitarian regimes – Hitler’s regime and Stalin’s regime, each “WE MUST BE OURSELVES!” of which was building his “new order” on the bones of millions of innocent victims and in denial of eternal Christian and universal values. In November 1944, after the return to Western Ukraine of the Bolshevik government and the passing into eternal life of Metropolitan Andrei, Vladyka Josyf took over the leadership of our Church. They describe that even a highly placed officer of the Soviet secret service, who was sent to L’viv in order to coordinate the violent liquidation of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church and, having seen the young bishop in bishop’s vestments during the [metropolitan’s] funeral procession, whether with regret or “with knowledge of the matter”, noted: “How many crosses have they placed on that bishop! How is he supposed to bear them all?” But in the night of April 11th, 1945 the new Primate of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, together with other bishops and wellknown priests, was arrested. He served the next 18 years behind the walls of the repressive Soviet penal system, at the same time he tirelessly and relentlessly carried his cross as a confessor of the faith and confirmed others in hope. His deep faith in God, faith in that the Lord’s Providence should defend the Church, which the Lord Himself established and that no one could destroy, were for him spiritual supports and guides in order not to lose himself in the midst of the prickly thorns of his terrible trials. Having received his release in 1963, thanks to the efforts of Saint Pope John XXIII and U.S. President John Kennedy, and, having arrived in Rome, Metropolitan Josyf never renounced his Ukrainian (though Soviet) citizenship. Even so, the “deported without right of return” archpastor wanted to be together with his suffering people, at least to show solidarity with his faithful who remained in the house of bondage. While in the West, he made great efforts in order to find and gather together those who, either by material need or political circumstances in the homeland, had been scattered throughout the world. The Patriarch and Confessor of the faith understood that without solid spiritual and intellectual foundations a people will be doomed to forget their roots, to disorganization and self-abasement, to utter subjugation and assimilation. Consequently, Vladyka Josyf Slipyj issues his first decrees “in the free world” with respect to the establishment and expansion of two institutions: the Ukrainian Catholic University and the Cathedral of St. Sophia. Notwithstanding his advanced age, and not lamenting about his energy and health having been broken by years of imprisonment, he visited each eparchy and every exarchate in the diaspora; he travelled to almost every parish, collecting not only funds but even rallying all “who were scattered” into one nation fullof-itsown-dignity under God in his Particular Church. Patriarch Josyf Cardinal Slipyj did not live to see by only a few years the collapse of the Soviet Union and its utter demise. He reposed in the Lord on September 7, 1984 and only in August 1992 his mortal remains “returned” in a stately and solemn manner from Rome to L’viv, after the Ukrainian people had gained their state’s independence and after the persecuted Church came out of the catacombs. But a true respite for his sleepless soul our great patriarch bequeathed only then when “if it be God’s will and the desire of the Ukrainian people, [they] place my coffin in the catacombs of the renewed Sobor of St. Sophia” in Kyiv as a sign of unity and sobornist’ of our entire nation and her unified Kyivan Church. We should all work on this task a great deal in order to fulfill the last will of this exemplary man of the Church! Meditating on the pages of the biography of Patriarch Josyf, we may assume that in his youth, dreaming about his future, he wasn’t even thinking that he would have to experience so many difficult times and trials. But, as we know from his memoirs, he always asked himself this question: “What does Lord expect from me?” And he often pondered on the question: “What will history say about me one day, with which I will stand before the Lord at the awesome tribunal of Christ?” It is understood that Josyf Slipyj became a great person not at any one moment. From day to day he grew in prayer, holiness, wisdom, in the sense of responsibility, and most of all – in fidelity to God’s will. His life, as the life of every one of us, was not a straight path, but rather a labyrinth, in which every choice is important. Because at every turn, it is possible to make an error, choosing not that particular path. In order not to be lost on this path, we need an inner compass that will suggest the correct path for us. The Servant of God Josyf did not search for guides in transient ideas or false hopes. In his pastoral letter “On the Unity in Christ” (June 3, 1976) he addressed his flock using direct advice: “We must be ourselves!” This “being ourselves” is being born in every one of us in the moment when in our prayer to our heavenly Father we recognize His will with reference to our life. And every stage in Patriarch Josyf’s biography is marked with this sign of authenticity, at the center of which Christ abides. He was himself, when he revealed in himself the attraction to learning and devoted his entire life to it, not so by his own academic work, but by creating the conditions and institutions for others. He was himself, when he felt his calling to the priesthood and devoted his whole self to this calling, in spite of the restrictions and the bans to exercise his ministry. He was himself, when he rejected the promised freedom and high positions if he were to renounce his Church. He was himself, when he, having found himself in the West, became the voice and symbol of the “silent Church” in the USSR and all the persecuted by the godless, totalitarian government. He was himself, when he continued to defend the right of the religious community, of which he was the head, to patriarchal dignity. Only this position gave him the opportunity not to be dependent from the stunning changes around him and to worthily move through all these turning points of history. Today, when we often hear that we live “in fluid times” or even “in the post-truth era”, when everything around is forever changing, nothing is firm and hopeful, truth does not exist, there are only “points of view”, that one is right whoever has power and money, and that one can become popular by means of cheap slogans and promises, — Patriarch Josyf’s invitation to authenticity, to “be yourself”, is once again extremely important. To be ourselves was never easy; it is even more difficult to exercise our calling in the uncertain times we are now experiencing. At first glance, it is much easier and more comfortable to adapt to change, to fit ourselves to external conditions, to refuse to recognize absolute Truth… But, woe to the person who ceases to be himself or herself, who loses himself or herself. The life of Patriarch Josyf, the raising-up of our Church from the catacombs and her further dynamic development bear witness that only the one overcomes the volatility and the fluidity of history, who invariably remains in his or her core the same as the Lord created him or her. This path, even though difficult and full of thorns, is possible, and it brings a person great inner satisfaction and joy because he or she exercises his or her Christian duty and does God’s will, and only in this way can he be himself or can she be herself. Therefore, in this Jubilee Year of our Patriarch Josyf, we encourage all to think about who we are and what our task is on this earthly pilgrimage to eternity, in our journey today “through hardships to the stars”. And may the Lord Jesus Christ Himself, Who alone is the Way, the Truth and the Life, be for us that leading star that will allow us to overcome all obstacles on this path of “WE MUST BE OURSELVES!” (continued from previous page) truly knowing our very selves through His Cross and Resurrection. The life and fate of Patriarch Josyf persuade us that, with deep faith and God’s help, a person of unbreakable will, who does not renounce his or her Godgiven being, who does not give up on his or her calling and who exercises his or her ministry, will overcome, whatever the circumstances, in a duel with evil and falsehood. The blessing of the Lord be upon you with His grace and love for mankind, always, now and for ever and ever.

+ SVIATOSLAV
Given in Kyiv at the Patriarchal Cathedral of the Resurrection of Christ, on the Feast of the Encounter of Our Lord Jesus Christ, 15 February 2017 A.D.

Understanding Our Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church — 20170312

As I shared in the last issue of this article, the Eastern Church’s unique approach to the observance of the Great Fast is to refrain from serving the Divine Liturgy during week days, which are “fast days”. I then raised a question which Western Catholics have frequently asked, namely, why do we distribute presanctified communion then during week days? Does this not contradict the liturgical principle that I enunciated?

To answer this question, I must share the Eastern Church’s thoughts on the second meaning of Communion. It is considered the source and sustaining power of any spiritual effort. Holy Communion is the fulfillment of all our efforts, the goal toward which we strive, the ultimate joy of our Christian life. Communion is also the source and beginning of our spiritual effort itself, that which makes it possible for us to know, to desire and to strive for a more perfect communion with our God.

When we take apart the word communion, it truly means union-with our God. This is also why we say that the task of this earthly life is to become more like Jesus. As we become more like Jesus, we enter into deeper UNION with our Triune God. Through the partaking of COMMUNION, we are given the gifts of courage, strength and true determination to enter into a deeper UNION with our God.

Of course we have to understand that Communion is a joining of our hearts and minds with Jesus, Who is God Himself in human form. When we partake of communion, we spiritually and psychologically declare our desire to be one with Jesus and, therefore one with God. We know, however, that to be one with God we must become like Jesus. This requires of any human being a change of heart and mind.

Partaking of Communion also joins us, in a unique way, to God’s Kingdom, albeit, at this present time, not in its fullness. Holy Communion, however, gives us a foretaste of His Kingdom.

So Communion is distributed during the week days of the Great Fast to support us in our efforts of personal change and transformation. As I have shared with my readers before, God has given us humans the potential to be like the Person of Jesus. We cannot, however, achieve the actualization of this potential without His help. We must cooperate with Him if we desire to actualize this potential. He supports us in this effort through His presence with us in Holy Communion. We truly believe that He is truly present to us when we partake of the transformed bread and wine which, we believe, are His Body and Blood – are Him!

SPIRITUAL ACTS Great Fast Week 1/2017

If you desire to make the Great Fast even more real to you, then add to your prayers and fasting Spiritual Acts of Mercy. This week, try sending a card or letter to someone you know is having a difficult time in life. Their difficulty may be because they are ill, lonely, involved in a very difficult relationship or addicted to some substance. Your support could make all the difference to them. They should not know, by the way, that you are doing this as a Lenten spiritual act. Just share with them the joy of life and the love of God.
May someone’s life be better because you care!

Reflections on the Scripture Readings for this Weekend — 20170226

In our Epistle reading this weekend we hear these words of Paul: “It is now the hour for you to wake from sleep, for our salvation is closer than when we first accepted the faith.” This words are very poignant as we begin the Great Fast – our preparation for Pascha.

Now is the time when we should think about our salvation! We should not put off for tomorrow what we can spiritually do today. God again gives us, through the Church, an opportunity to increase the actualization of our potential to become more like Jesus Christ. This, of course, is the major task of this earthly life! Let us wisely use this time of the Great Fast!

In our Gospel reading we hear this exhortation:

Make it your practice… to store up heavenly treasure…. Remember, where your treasure is, there your heart is also.

On this last weekend before the Great Fast, we are reminded that the task of life is to seek forgiveness by extending forgiveness to others. This is one of the reasons, I believe, that we recall the Biblical story of Adam and Eve’s expulsion from Paradise. The story highlights how self-centered we humans and how such behavior is destructive to our relationship with God and others. They only thought of themselves and not their relationship with God.

The one temptation common to all humans, it seems, is the temptation of self-aggrandizement and desire for power. We see it rampant in our modern society. Narcissism is strong and prevalent. What people fail to realize, however, is that when we give into this temptation, we typically hurt others as well as ourselves since it lessens us as children of God. This is why, I believe, our Eastern Church would have us begin the Great Fast with asking for forgiveness from God and from one another (this weekend is also called Forgiveness Weekend). If we allow narcissism to rule our lives, we can never actualize the potential to become like Jesus. Why? Because we already think we are great and don’t think we must change. One author has written this: One should love oneself enough not to love oneself too much. What good advice! So our work during the Great Fast is to work on bringing balance into our lives.

To achieve this, we must first desire to change, admit that we need to change and then work to change.

Learning Our Faith From the Greek Fathers of the Church — 20170226

In this article I have tried to express the thoughts of the Greek Fathers of the Church and, in doing so, I have, of course, mentioned the struggles that the Church encountered during the first seven/eight centuries. The struggles were namely about Who Jesus Is. I’ve mentioned in passing several heresies, and thought that I would now look at them in a little more depth. The first, of course, being the ARIAN CONTROVERSY.

While for years the Church had reflected fruitfully on the person and work of Christ, it took a specific individual to prod the Church to formalize or crystallize its teaching regarding the divinity of Jesus. How sad? At Alexandria in the early fourth century, a priest by the name of Arius began to question seriously the possibility that Jesus could be divine, at least in the same sense that God or the Father was divine.

We can best understand Arius’ position by sneaking a peek at his own mail. In a letter written to his friend Eusebius of Nicomedia, Arius complains of the trouble that has engulfed him in Alexandria. Arius relates that “the bishop greatly injures and persecutes us and does all he can against us, trying to drive us out of the city as godless men.” Why was Arius encountering such opposition?

Arius writes that

we do not agree with him [Alexander, the bishop of Alexandria] when he says publically, “Always Father, always Son,” “Father and Son together,” “The Son exists unbegottenly with God,” “The eternal begotten”, “Unbegotten-only-one”, “Neither in thought nor by a single instant is God before the Son,” Always God, always son,” “The son is of God Himself.”

Arius is displeased with Bishop Alexander’s description of the Son, largely because Alexander is leaning over backwards in his insistence that the son has always been with the Father. There is “no instant,” as Alexander phrases it, when the Father was without the Son. Indeed, to be Father is to have a Son: “always God always Son.” If so the son must be divine in essence, just as the Father is. Or so it would seem.

Arius refused to accept Alexander’s formulations. Alexander’s position raises a number of problems that appear insurmountable to Arius. Thus the beginning of the heresy of Arius. More to follow

The Spirituality of the Christian East — 20170226

In the last issue I was dealing with the 29th Step on John’s Ladder, namely DISPASSION. One of the aspects of Dispassion is, of course, Theosis. As my readers may know, if they have been following this article, Theosis is the Eastern Church’s spiritual development process by which personal change or transformation is supported. This process has also been called deification. Deification is to become “holy for I am holy(Leviticus 11:44). So the idea of deification was already represented in the Old Testament (OT) but, since God had not yet become incarnate in the Person of Jesus, the people of the OT had no model that they could imitate. Matthew (5:48) describes it in this manner: the purpose of life is to become “perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect”. This has been made possible by the only human being who is God by nature: Jesus Christ. Because the second Person of the Holy Trinity became what we are and shared in our humanity, we can become what He is and share in His divine glory.

But if no created being can become God – for He is “beyond all being” – how do we explain this contradiction? The Eastern Church explains it by a distinction between God’s essence (what God is by nature) and His energies (what we can experience of God by His grace and condescension). God is by nature love, and by His grace we become love; He is by nature holy, and by His grace we are made holy; God is by nature eternal, and by His grace we have everlasting life. Maximus the Confessor explained it in the following way:

A sure warrant for looking forward with hope to deification of human nature is provided by the incarnation of God, which makes man god to the same degree as God himself became man.

Theosis, or dispassion, cannot be acquired with the intellect, but only by experience, meaning by synergy. We cannot be saved by faith alone, by grace alone, or by works alone. More the follow.